Skip to Content

16 Heavenly Recipes to Impress at the Church Potluck

Share this post or pin it for later!

Summer is the perfect time to enjoy good eats and even better company at a potluck, party, or family gathering. Impress everyone this Sunday with these tantalizing (and surprisingly easy) recipes.

Impress everyone with your mouthwatering homemade creations using these irresistible potluck recipes.

Frozen Watermelon

Church potluck recipes
Image credit: Shutterstock.

Prepare some frozen watermelon for a refreshing, naturally sweet treat. Watermelon is a summertime essential, and freezing it enhances the crisp texture. The entire family will enjoy snacking on the cubed fruit pieces.

Frozen Watermelon Recipe

Ham and Cheese Sliders

Church potluck recipes
Image credit: Shutterstock.

Do you want a tasty handheld snack for your next party? These ham and cheese sliders are just what you need. With tangy mustard and sweet Hawaiian rolls, you won’t be able to resist these small, buttery sandwiches.

Ham and Cheese Sliders Recipe

Berry Trifle

Church potluck recipes
Image credit: Shutterstock.

While berry trifle seems like an upscale dessert, it’s deceptively easy to make. The traditional English treat boasts layers of fruit jam, berries, sweet biscuits, and a cream cheese-based filling. This trifle recipe from Once Upon a Chef is simple but addictively delicious.

Summer Berry Trifle Recipe

Buffalo Chicken Dip

Church potluck recipes
Image credit: Shutterstock.

Buffalo chicken dip is a classic recipe for any potluck. It’s savory and creamy, perfect for dipping with chips, carrots, or celery. This crowd favorite whips up in less than an hour and will have everyone returning for seconds.

Buffalo Chicken Dip Recipe

Pasta Salad

Church potluck recipes
Image credit: Shutterstock.

It wouldn’t be a proper potluck without a hearty pasta salad. This recipe combines pasta with fresh vegetables, cheese, and herbs for a delicious side dish. Prepare the salad the night before your event to save time and let the flavors thoroughly combine.

Easy Pasta Salad Recipe

Crockpot Meatballs

Church potluck recipes
Image credit: Shutterstock.

Make a batch of these delicious crockpot meatballs for your next church potluck. You can make meatballs from scratch, but no one will tell the difference if you use frozen. This recipe perfectly balances sweet with savory, and the prep is unbelievably easy.

Crockpot Meatballs Recipe

Deviled Eggs

Church potluck recipes
Image credit: Shutterstock.

Deviled eggs are a hit any time of the year. Many recipes claim to be the best, but this one has been a staple for decades. Make these creamy bitesize snacks in advance to get out of the kitchen and enjoy the company of friends and family.

Classic Deviled Eggs Recipe

Strawberry Icebox Cake

Church potluck recipes
Image credit: Shutterstock.

Everyone will think you spent hours preparing this Strawberry Icebox Cake. Thankfully, the recipe couldn’t be more straightforward, with only five ingredients and three steps. You’ll have a refreshing, sweet treat that tastes like summer in every bite.

Strawberry Icebox Cake Recipe

Potato Salad

Church potluck recipes
Image credit: Shutterstock.

Forget bland, store-bought potato salad. This recipe is flavorful and refreshing on a hot summer day. Everyone will be impressed by its tastiness, and you can easily adjust the quantities to make an extra large batch.

Best Potato Salad Recipe

7 Layer Dip

Church potluck recipes
Image credit: Shutterstock.

If you’ve never tried a 7 layer dip, you’re missing out. It’s affordable, quick to prepare, and always a popular party appetizer. With layers of beans, guacamole, cheese, and salsa, you’ll be obsessed after one bite.

7 Layer Dip Recipe

Squash Casserole

Church potluck recipes
Image credit: Shutterstock.

Nothing says “Southern potluck” like a traditional squash casserole. This dish is creamy, crunchy, buttery, and cheesy. What’s not to love?

Old-School Squash Casserole Recipe

Slow-Cooker Pulled Pork

Church potluck recipes
Image credit: Shutterstock.

Slow-cooker pulled pork is one of the easiest meals to bring to a potluck. Just dump all the ingredients into a crockpot, let it cook overnight, and voila. You can get creative with seasonings to add a twist to the classic barbecue flavors.

Slow-Cooker BBQ Pulled Pork Recipe

Homemade Lemonade

Church potluck recipes
Image credit: Shutterstock.

If you’re short on time but don’t want to arrive at the potluck empty-handed, consider bringing a big batch of homemade lemonade. This recipe calls for three ingredients you likely already have on hand. Within minutes, you’ll have a sweet, tart, and refreshing drink ready to sip.

Homemade Lemonade Recipe

Baked Beans

Image credit: Shutterstock.

Baked beans are a must at any summer gathering. Use canned beans as your base and enhance them with spices and seasonings. The How Sweet Eats recipe balances sweet, salty, and tangy flavors in one easy-to-make side.

Baked Beans Recipe

Cowboy Caviar

Image credit: Shutterstock.

Become everyone’s favorite party guest by bringing cowboy caviar to share. This bean and vegetable salad includes seasonal ingredients like corn, so every bite bursts with freshness. Enjoy the dish alone, or pair it with chips for a savory dip.

Cowboy Caviar Recipe

Pinwheels

Image credit: Shutterstock.

Tortilla roll-ups, also known as pinwheels, are a fantastic potluck option. You can make a large batch that will satisfy everyone in 10 minutes or less. There are several recipe variations if you want to add a spicy kick or Mexican flare.

Ham and Cheese Pinwheels Recipe

Elevate any event with a seasonally-inspired mocktail

Image credit: Shutterstock.

Mocktails are a must for gatherings with loved ones of all ages. These family-friendly drink recipes are full of fresh summer flavors.

Mocktail Recipes: 10 Non-Alcoholic Drinks to Make This Summer

Take your s’mores games to the next level

Image credit: Shutterstock.

Nothing beats roasting marshmallows over the fire. Switch things up this summer and give your boring old s’mores a unique twist.

S’mores Treats: 4 Sweet and Savory Recipes

Related Posts